Despite these passages bearing a distant resemblance to the question, Berkeley never.
In other words, by this second definition, sound is what we hear, i.e., the perception in our brains. So if sound is what we hear, and no one is around to hear the tree fall, then it doesn’t make a sound! That’s opposite to the answer we had earlier. Which answer is correct? Apr 20, “If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?” was a philosophical question posed by George Berkeley to explore various concepts relating to perception; is a sound only a sound if someone hears it, how much can we truly know about the unobserved world and.
“If a tree falls in the forest ” In shortened form is an idiom meaning opinions/thoughts/actions etc. are ineffective and inconsequential if no one ever knows about them. The sentence is originally a philosophical allegory or a scientific thought experiment depending on who you ask. The answer is quite simple if answering on a physical level: Yes and No! Yes, it makes a sound, that being a disturbance in the fluidic medium, air.
When the tree falls if a tree falls and no one hears it meaning causes a disturbance in the air pressure field in the woods and that pressure field emanates away from the fallen shrubgrinding.barted Reading Time: 5 mins.